Tuesday, October 4, 2011
Noir Urbanisms; Dystopic Images of the Modern City
The Dystopic Fragments of Bombay Cinema
Ranjani Muzumdar
an active figure whose rage makes him see the city with a heightened
perception. This perceptual entry into the city does not generate urban images
through modes of distraction (jlanerie) but through sustained vigilante
action. 22 The figure of the vigilante is an imaginative urban figure, whose defiance
of the law produces a different order of urban mobility. As against the
aimless loitering associated with many urban figures, Madhav Apte's purposeful
mobility creates a heightened order of perception. This vigilante vision
operates like a counter-flaneur imagination that is not made of surfaces but
of dystopic "excavations:'
22 For Walter Benjamin, the flaneur was a "panoramically situated" spectator who
observed and absorbed through random selection the visual impressions generated
by the new commodity space of industrial modernity. The flaneur's gaze was
fragmented and adventurous as he/she confronted the magical world of the commodity
displayed in shop windows of city streets. As a perceptual mode flanerie
depends on distraction and a free movement of subjectivity where the gaze is organized
according to a "spontaneous, unmitigated and seemingly unsystematic
turn of attention towards the surface phenomena of the exterior world:' Encke
Gleber, The Art of Taking a Walk: Flanerie, Literature and Film in Weimar Culture
(Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1998), 26.
Society, says the philosopher Zygmut Bauman, is like a thin film of order
that functions like a cover-up operation to deny and suppress the chaos
beneath. For Bauman, chaos is a terrifying experience for those gripped by
the "routine of the given:' Chaos is like a "break in, 'the given', an irruption,
a crevice in the otherwise solid rock of normality, a hole in the smoothly
flowing routine of being:'24
24 Zygmut Bauman, Life in Fragments: Essays in Postmodern Morality (Cambridge, MA: Blackwell, 1995), 14-15.
Monday, September 12, 2011
Notes on Eric Gordon. Chapter 5 The Operative City
the technocratic justification for wide-scale urban renewal closely paralleled the growing popular faith in rational systems and thinking machines.
By the I940s, some planners were talking about multinucleated urban growth patterns, downplaying the importance of a central business district for the life of the city.
The Bunker Hill renewal project in downtown Los Angeles was one of the largest and most dramatic in the country
Urban renewal was as much psychological as physical.
Urban renewal was a corrective process. It was meant to destroy decades of ingrained experiences and perceptions of the city and replace them with a stable, reliable, distant image.
Norbert Wiener described as operative: "Operative images, which perform
the functions of their original, may or may not bear a pictorial likeness to it.
Whether they do or not, they may replace the original in its action, and this is a
much deeper similarity"
replace the urban imagery of chaos and degradation with one of order and function.
the spectatorship associated with the operative city produced a functional aesthetic through the assemblage of logically consistent mechanical parts. Possession was still important; only now, the city was constructed through a spectator's ability to possess and control its functionality.
THE ROAD TO RENEWAL
the newly granted power of imminent domain allowed the city to condemn the building and take it from the owner at below-market rates.
In short time, the rhetoric of redevelopment translated to the new rhetoric of "renewal."
The premise ... was that if a large enough parcel was cleared and built anew, natural urban processes would extend the positive effects of development outward. If the development area was too small, however, renewal efforts would not be successful.
THE BATTLE OF BUNKER HILL
Bunker Hill came to symbolize confusion, corruption, convalescence, and the degradation of values.
the city was no longer seen within this constructivist context. It was presented as something that could be presented all at once- completely within the parameters of human understanding. Accordingly, if the city as a whole was "subject to human mastery and control," then the city could be produced from scratch. Whatever could be understood could be manufactured.
The war demonstrated that technology could easily overwhelm the intentions of its creator. Left unchecked, progress could be dangerous. For this reason, technological displays turned away from speculation and toward control.
THE OPERATIVE IMAGE
Norbert Wiener's 1948 book, Cybernetics.
study of how systems communicate with themselves in order to maintain internal cohesion, and how they interact with other systems.
People, cities, and societies were no different than machines.
he called the result of any system's production of another system an of operative
image. Every system creates in its own image- God and man, man and machine.
little emphasis on the specific architectural references in each of the structures-only on their combined function as urban image. The operative image was the foundation of a Concept-city that sought to distance the spectator from his central position of aggregator
Heidegger - This is how the modern world is knowable. The world is an image capable of existing alongside and not within experience. the world conceived and grasped as picture = World Picture
Just as machines were programmed to represent human thought, so were cities tasked with the challenge of representing urban function.
MACHINE INTELLIGENCE
If scientists cracked the code of human thought, the mind could be rendered a useful servant instead of a persistent antagonist.
Descartes believed that objects were totally contained in the outside world and known to the mind only through their representations.
Turing test - versatility, Universal Machine
The modern city should be able to pass Turing's test: it should be programmed to make its creators think that it is thinking. Through scientific planning it can solve urban problems and increase economic value far more efficiently than any human advisors.
OUTCOME PREDICTION AS URBAN DESIGN
This rational city stemmed from an urban planning discourse most notably initiated by Le Corbusier's Radiant City (1970). All activities were logically separated in Radiant City; leisure and commerce were physically removed from one another in order to assure order and easy maintenance of the urban plan.
The master plan was conceived as a Universal Machine, organizing the outputs of each part and building an information structure based on their activities- all within the careful structure of a controlled environment.
Mumford's The City in History (1961), Jane Jacobs's The Death and Life of Great American Cities ( r 9 6 r) was strongly influential in the growing antagonism toward urban renewal.
Kevin Lynch's The Image of the City (1960) suggested possibilities for human intervention into the operative city. Cognitive Mapping
Colin Rowe and Fred Koetter, in their book Collage City (1978)
urban problems should not be understood as issues of "simplicity" or "disorganized complexity,"
both of which characterized modern science. Instead, she argued, the city was a manifestation of organized complexity- a complex system quite distinct from Forrester's characterization. Organized complexity was not entirely predictable; it had order, but part of that order was its lack of predictability. The sidewalk was, by design, unpredictable.
Susan Sontag: A New Visual Code
A new visual code
In her Essay On Photography Sontag says that the evolution of modern technology has changed the viewer in three key ways. She calls this the emergence of a new visual code.
Firstly, Sontag suggests that modern photography, with its convenience and ease, has created an overabundance of visual material. As photographing is now a practice of the masses, due to a drastic decrease of camera size and increase of ease in developing photographs, we are left in a position where “just about everything has been photographed” (Sontag, Susan, (1977), On Photography 3). We now have so many images available to us of: things, places, events and people from all over the world, and of not immediate relevance to our own existence, that our expectations of what we have the right to view, want to view or should view has been drastically affected. Arguably, gone are the days that we felt entitled to view only those things in our immediate presence or that affected our micro world; we now seem to feel entitled to gain access to any existing images. “In teaching us a new visual code, photographs alter and enlarge our notion of what is worth looking at and what we have the right to observe” (3). This is what Sontag calls a change in the “ethics of seeing” (3).
Secondly, Sontag comments on the effect of modern photography on our education, claiming that photographs “now provide most of the knowledge people have about the look of the past and the reach of the present”(4). Without photography only those few people who had been there would know what the Egyptian pyramids or the Parthenon look like, yet most of us have a good idea of the appearance of these places. Photography teaches us about those parts of the world that are beyond our touch in ways that literature can not.
Thirdly, Sontag also talked about the way in which photography desensitizes its audience. Sontag introduced this discussion by telling her own story of the first time she saw images of horrific human experience. At twelve years old, Sontag found images of holocaust camps and was so distressed by them she says “When I looked at those photographs something broke... something went dead, something is still crying” (20). Sontag argues that there was no good to come from her seeing these images as a young girl, before she fully understood what the holocaust was. For Sontag the viewing of these images has left her a degree more numb to any following horrific image she viewed, as she had been desensitized. According to this argument, “Images anesthetize” and the open accessibility to them is a negative result of photography (20).
Sontag examines the relationship between photography and reality. Photographs are depicted as a representation of realism. Sontag claimed that “such images are indeed able to usurp reality because first of all a photograph is not only an image, an interpretation of the real; it is also a trace, something directly stenciled off the real (Sontag, Susan (1982), The Image World 350). It is a resemblance of the real as the photograph becomes an extension of the subject. However, the role of the photograph has changed, as copies destroy the idea of an experience. The image has altered to convey information and become an act of classification. Sontag highlights the notion that photographs are a way of imprisoning reality- making the memory stand still. Ultimately images are surveillance of events that trigger the memory. In modern society, photographs are a form of recycling the real. When a moment is captured it is assigned a new meaning as people interpret the image in their own manner. Sontag claims that images desensitize the reality, as people's perceptions are distorted by the construction of the photograph. However this has not stopped people from consuming images; there is still a demand for more photographs.
Sontag observed some uses of photography, “Photography has become one of the principal devices for experiencing something, for giving an appearance of participation” (Sontag,1977 10), such as memorizing and providing evidence. She also states that “to collect photographs is to collect the world.” (Sontag,1997 3)
Sontag believes that photography implies that we know about the world if we accept it as the camera records it. She states that photography has ‘become one of the principal devices for experiencing something, for giving an appearance of participation’.[15] She refers to photographs as memento mori, where to take a photograph is to participate in another person’s mortality, vulnerability and mutability. The progression from written word to an image shifts the interpretation from the author to the receiver. Sontag believes however that ‘photographed images do not seem to be statements about the world so much as pieces of it, miniatures of reality that anyone can make or acquire’.[16] It is a slice in time and in effect, is more memorable than moving images for example, videos. It fills the gaps in our mind of the past and present.[17] Even though photography has such effect, there are limits to photographic knowledge of the world. The limitations are that it can never be interpreted ethical or political knowledge.[18] It will always be some kind of sentimentalism, whether cynical or humanist. [18]
Mumford On Cities
"The city multiplies man’s power to think, to remember, to educate, to communicate, and so to make possible associations which bridge and bypass nations, cultures. This mixture, this cosmopolitanism, is the chief source of the city’s vitality. And we must enlarge and enrich it as we move towards a new urban form.” Mumford
Wednesday, September 7, 2011
Chicago Architecture Foundation
Extended Due to Popular Demand!
COST Free and open to the public
HOURS 7 days a week from 9am-6:30pm
LOCATION Atrium Gallery, 224 South Michigan Avenue
How does a region as vast and complex as Chicago take shape? What are the goals of officials, real estate developers, corporations, and citizens who structure urban life? Chicago Model City tells the stories behind the planning of Chicago.
Rapid growth, innovative design, and a diverse population helped make Chicago a symbol of the modern city. Beyond this, Chicago became a model: a means of understanding cities and citizens everywhere. This exhibition explores Chicago’s role as a model for city-building.
The centerpiece of Chicago Model City is a 320-square-foot model of downtown that enables you to see Chicago as you’ve never seen it before. It is the only accurate and up-to-date model of the city.
Chicago Model City also features a unique 1950s model of the Eisenhower Expressway and Blue Line; a digital visualization of demolition and rebuilding on Chicago’s Near South Side; a model portraying the green renovation of the Willis Tower; a visualization of runway expansions at O’Hare International Airport; and an exploration of the 1909 Plan of Chicago.
Saturday, September 3, 2011
Notes on Susan Sontag, On Photography
Photographs do not seem to be statements about the world so much as pieces of it, miniatures of reality, that anyone can make or acquire.
as a mass art form, photography is not practiced by most people as an art. It is mainly a social rite, a defense against anxiety, and a tool of power
The industrialization of photography permitted its rapid absorption into rational—that is, bureaucratic—ways of running society. …photographs became part of the general furniture of the environment---touchstones and confirmations of that reductive approach to reality which is considered realistic
A family's photograph album is generally about the extended family and, often, is all that remains of it.
As photographs give people an imaginary possession of a past that is unreal, they also help people to take possession of space in which they are insecure.
In America, the photographer is not simply the person who records the past, but the one who invents it.
In the final analysis, style is art. And art is nothing more or less than various modes of stylized, dehumanized representation.
It is not altogether wrong to say that there is no such thing as a bad photograph - only less interesting, less relevant, less mysterious ones.
Life is not significant details, illuminated by a flash, fixed forever. Photographs are.
Mallarme said that everything in the world exists in order to end in a book. Today everything exists to end in a photograph.
So successful has been the camera's role in beautifying the world that photographs, rather than the world, have become the standard of the beautiful.
Surrealism is a bourgeois disaffection; that its militants thought it universal is only one of the signs that it is typically bourgeois.
The taste for quotations (and for the juxtaposition of incongruous quotations) is a Surrealist taste.
The camera makes everyone a tourist in other people's reality, and eventually in one's own.
The painter constructs, the photographer discloses.
To photograph is to confer importance.
To take a photograph is to participate in another person's mortality, vulnerability, mutability. Precisely by slicing out this moment and freezing it, all photographs testify to time's relentless melt.
Travel becomes a strategy for accumulating photographs.
What pornography is really about, ultimately, isn't sex but death.
Readings for 9/7
September 7
Theory and Background
Susan Sontag, On Photography (New York: Picador, 1973), pp. 3-82.
Stefanie Harris, “Rilke, Photography, and the City,” New German Critique, No. 99, (Fall,
2006), pp. 121-149
Eric Gordon, Chapter 1: “More Than the Sum of its Parts: The White City and Amateur
Photography,” in The Urban Spectator: American Concept Cities From Kodak to Google
(Hanover and London: University Press of New England, 2010), pp. 21-42.
Suggested background reading: Peter Bacon Hales, Silver Cities: The Photography of
American Urbanization, 1839-1915 (Philadelphia: Temple University Press, 1984).
Wednesday, August 31, 2011
Digital History
Need some inspiration? Look at a list of websites built in Omeka.net.
Assignment #1
What is a city? What are some of the frameworks for considering and theorizing the mediated city? These are the questions that permeate this week's readings. In "What is a City?" Lewis Mumford views the city as a social institution and describes it thusly: "The city in its complete sense, then is a geographic plexus, an economic organization, an institutional process, a theater of social action, and an aesthetic symbol of collective unity." Mumford's focus is not on "the built environment" as such but rather the city as a theater in which "man's more purposive activities are focused and work out, through conflicting and cooperating personalities, events, groups, into more significant culminations." In "Visions of a New Reality" Frederic Stout chronicles emergence of a new visual culture and observes that "each historical era creates characteristic forms of expression and explanatory discourse that reflect, indeed construct, the social reality of the period." Stout examines the role of photography in creating and capturing the social reality of urban life in a mediated city. Eric Gordon in his Introduction to The Urban Spectator: American Concept Cities From Kodak to Google, outlines his concept of possessive spectatorship, "a way of looking that incorporates immediate experience with the desire for subsequent possession" of the traces of that experience. Gordon is chiefly concerned with "how the dominant understandings of technologies, shaped through metaphors ... collide with the consumptive practices of spectators" and how "possessive spectatorship ... structured by architectural, urbanistic, and technological innovations, has influenced the shape of the American Concept-city." Georg Simmel outlines a more sociological-psychological framework in this "Metropolis and Mental Life." Simmel examines the influence of the environmental stimuli on the development of what he calls "mental life," namely the predominance of intellectuality and logic, the protective mechanism called reserve, the calculability of the money economy and the appearance of the characteristic blasé attitude as indicative of metropolitan influences. Michel de Certeau takes a more literary approach to theorizing cities. He views cities as texts, composed of "the tallest letters in the world", described by walkers who commit "speech acts" in a "rhetoric of walking", and "whose bodies follow the ... urban text they write without being able to read it." De Certeau draws upon Baudelaire's notion of the flâneur, the person who walks the city to understand the city and is both part of the crowd and simultaneously apart from it.
Tuesday, August 30, 2011
Notes on Frederic Stout "Visions of a New Reality"
Visual Culture,” (first published in 1999), The City Reader, (Fifth Edition) Richard T.
LeGates and Frederic Stout, eds., (London and New York: Routledge, 2011), pp. 150-
153.
In "Visions of a New Reality" Frederic Stout chronicles emergence of a new visual culture, one fostered by and focused on the city. Drawing from Marx, Stout begins with the observation that "each historical era creates characteristic forms of expression and explanatory discourse that reflect, indeed construct, the social reality of the period." Focusing mainly on the realm of visual arts, Stout begins his story with the "dramatic and rapidly changing social realities" embedded within the cities of the Industrial Revolution. It was during this turbulent period that new "forms of expression and modes of discourse arose" and a "whole new kind of visual culture emerged, rooted in the observation of the new urban reality, both social and physical."
Not surprisingly this new visual culture traces its beginnings to the popular newspapers of the day. Stout reviews the early development of illustrated journalism and its role in meeting "the growing demand for information and entertainment on the part of a marginally literate but fully enfranchised working class and petit bourgeoisie." While establishing a characteristic style of static composite picture, it was soon supplanted by a new technology of representation - photography. Stout argues that it was this technological turn which established the importance of the social reality of urban life to the new visual culture. Photography "perfectly exemplified the spirit of the modern age" - ubiquitous, immediate, democratic and kinetic. While all aspects of the human subject found their way into the frame, it was the urban subjects - "the inescapable social and physical reality of the modern city" that took prominence. From the spectacles of disaster, to the frenetic city sketches, to the monumental architecture, to the plight of human suffering and injustice, photography embraced and uplifted them all as subject; a subject in which the viewer often recognized herself and her own experiences. As living and working conditions deteriorated Through the Great Depression photographers gradually turned to "the intersection of art and social protest."
While photography did not complete the project of understanding cities visually, it did set the stage for future developments. Soon it was connected to narrative, particularly to the "urban narrative" and with the new kinetic visual representation morphed into cinema. But still, in "the modern city, it is the image ... that is paramount both as spectacle and revelation."
Notes on Lewis Mumford's "What is a City?"
In "What is a City?" Lewis Mumford, one of the most preeminent urban historians descries what he sees as the chief handicap to modern city planning, the failure to understand and embrace the social function of the city. Rather than view the city as a "purely physical fact" Mumford suggests a broader view and asks "what is the city as a social institution?" and offers the following answer; "The city in its complete sense, then is a geographic plexus, an economic organization, an institutional process, a theater of social action, and an aesthetic symbol of collective unity." Mumford's focus is not on "the built environment" as such but rather the city as locus of social networks and a theater in which "man's more purposive activities are focused and work out, through conflicting and cooperating personalities, events, groups, into more significant culminations." While the nature of the built environment no doubt influence this social drama, Mumford sees its role as primarily that of a well designed stage set, to facilitate and intensify the performance of the actors upon it. Mumford asserts that the quintessential character of the city is to "create drama," for although all of the necessary physical structures of cities may exist elsewhere, namely in the suburbs, it is this "opportunity for social disharmony and conflict" that only urban densities and proximities provide. A city may be viewed according to Mumford as "a special framework directed toward the creation of differentiated opportunities for a common life and a significant social drama."
Mumford argues that it is this consideration that ultimately should determine such limiting factors as size, density, area and layout of a city, rather than topographical or technological concerns. Since it is most important to express "size as a function of the social relationships to be served" it is natural that Mumford should advocate for small scale clusters of communities "adequately spaced and bounded" known as the "polynucleated city" as opposed to the monopolistic, hypertrophied and aggrandizing "mononucleated city" with its single focal point. Dubbing it the Highwayless Town, Mumford sees an eventual trend toward this form of limited, decentralized and dissociated urban development through the effective zoning of functions in which "the various functional parts of the structure are isolated topographically as urban islands appropriately designed for their specific use." It is through this deliberate design and articulation that the necessary social concentration for social drama may be best achieved.
Tuesday, August 23, 2011
Notes on Micheal de Certeau's "Walking in the City"
coincidentia oppositorum is a Latin phrase meaning coincidence of opposites. It is a neoplatonic term attributed to 15th century German polymath Nicholas of Cusa in his essay, De Docta Ignorantia (1440). Mircea Eliade, a 20th century historian of religion, used the term extensively in his essays about myth and ritual, describing the coincidentia oppositorum as "the mythical pattern". Psychiatrist Carl Jung, philosopher and Islamic Studies professor Henry Corbin as well as Jewish philosophers Gershom Scholem and Abraham Joshua Heschel also used the term. In alchemy, coincidentia oppositorum is a synonym for conjunction, the fifth process.
The term is also used in describing a revelation of the oneness of things previously believed to be different. Such insight into the unity of things is a kind of transcendence, and is found in various mystical traditions. The idea occurs in the traditions of Tantric Hinduism and Buddhism, in German mysticism, Taoism, Zen and Sufism, among others.
---
Icarus/Daedalus
---
Texturology (texture, Latin: features of a structure of something considered as a whole, caused by an arrangement of its components; and logos, Greek: knowledge, doctrine)
---
"They walk-an elementary form of this experience of the city; they are walkers, Wandersmiinner, whose bodies follow the thicks and thins of an urban "text" they write without being able to read it." {like the character in Auster's "City of Glass" New York Trilogy}
---
"Within this ensemble, I shall try to locate the practices that are foreign to the "geometrical" or "geographical" space of visual, panoptic, or theoretical constructions."
"These practices of space refer to a specific form of operations ("ways of operating"), to "another spatiality" (an "anthropological," poetic and mythic experience of space), and to an opaque and blind mobility characteristic of the bustling city. A migrational, or metaphorical, city thus slips into the clear text of the planned and readable city."
"Linking the city to the concept never makes them identical, but it plays on their progressive symbiosis: to plan a city is both to think the very plurality of the real and to make that way of thinking the plural effective; it is to know how to articulate it and be able to do it."
Rhetoric of Walking as "figures of speech"
"Synecdoche makes more dense: it amplifies the detail and miniaturizes the whole. Asyndeton cuts out: it undoes continuity and undercuts its plausibility."
Notes on Eric Gordon - "The Urban Spectator" Introduction
"Can the city, as an entity, continue to matter when digital networks
enable public gathering without requiring the public to gather in physical
space? The answer to these questions is a resounding "yes." The modern
American city has never been bereft of these complications- from the handheld
camera at the end of the nineteenth century to the mobile phone at the
end of the twentieth, the city has always been a mediated construct."
"The city enters into the cultural imaginary as a hodgepodge of disconnected signifiers, often organized by the technologies that produce them."
"Communication technologies ... provide the spectator the unique opportunity to at once experience space and possess its traces."
possessive spectatorship -- "the spectatorship structured around the desire for possessing these traces ... a way of looking that incorporates immediate experience with the desire for subsequent possession."
"The American city grew up in parallel to the technologies that enabled its possession."
"I argue that emerging media practices transformed urban practices by naturalizing
the notion that individual spectators could not only see the Conceptcity
but also possess it. And most importantly, I argue that this spectatorship
altered the material shape of the city as urban plans were drafted to meet the
expectations of a spectator eager to take control of the city's assembly."
Urban Practices/Concept-city
The concept of possessive spectatorship places a decisive emphasis on visuality.
Visuality is fundamentally embodied.
The notion that visuality and its corresponding technologies might alter the
way one engages with the urban environment is not particularly new.
Kodak camera -- "keeps his senses alert for the picture possibilities about him"
Ever since the handheld camera prompted shifts in the framing of everyday
vision, the process of collecting those visions has been framed through metaphor.
[I am] concerned with how the dominant understandings of technologies, shaped through metaphors of one kind or another, collide with the consumptive practices of spectators. And ultimately how this collision serves to shape the city.
Tbe view from on high is a fiction or facsimile of the city, like those drafted by planners or cartographers, but it does not provide access to the practices that actually compose the city.
Urban practices, themselves devoid of vision, always operate within what
de Certeau calls the Concept-city, a space of total vision. Each of the people on
that street corner is blindly interacting with their immediate urban spaces
(despite their use of media devices), while their understanding of those spaces
is framed by the evolving Concept-city (enhanced by those same devices).
Whether directly mediated or not, each practice of the city is embedded within some articulation of the Concept-city.
"De Certeau aligns this phenomenon to Ferdinand de Saussure's characterization of langue and
parole-the overall logic of any language (langue) is implicit in each individual speech act (parole). All urban experiences, he argues, comprise both the phenomenological encounter (the blind, embodied practices of the street) and the overarching logic of the Concept-city (the complete picture)."
Note: The term flâneur comes from the French masculine noun flâneur—which has the basic meanings of "stroller", "lounger", "saunterer", "loafer"—which itself comes from the French verb flâner, which means "to stroll". Charles Baudelaire developed a derived meaning of flâneur—that of "a person who walks the city in order to experience it". Because of the term's usage and theorization by Baudelaire and numerous thinkers in economic, cultural, literary and historical fields, the idea of the flâneur has accumulated significant meaning as a referent for understanding urban phenomena and modernity.